Bitcoin – The Internet of Money

This post is old – I wrote it for Wired, which just published an excerpt in “The Wired World in 2014” issue, but the article was written in July. Apologies for the obsolescence.

Bitcoin will eventually be recognized as a platform for building new financial services.

Most people are only familiar with (b)itcoin the electronic currency, but more important is (B)itcoin, with a capital B, the underlying protocol, which encapsulates and distributes the functions of contract law.

Bitcoin encapsulates four fundamental technologies:

  • Digital Signatures – these can’t be forged and allow one party to securely verify a transaction with another.
  • Peer-to-Peer networks, like BitTorrent or TCP/IP – difficult to take down and no central trust
    required.
  • Proof-of-Work prevents users from spending the same money twice, without needing a central authority to distinguish valid from invalid transactions. Bitcoin creates an incentive for miners, who run powerful computers in the network, to validate transactions and to secure them from future tampering. The miners are paid by “discovering” new coins, and anyone with computational resources can anonymously and democratically become a miner.
  • Distributed Ledger – Bitcoin puts a history of each and every transaction into every wallet. This “block chain” means that anyone can validate that a given transaction was performed.

Thanks to these technical underpinnings, bitcoins are scarce (Central Banks can’t inflate them away), durable (they don’t degrade), portable (can be carried and transmitted electronically or as numbers in your head), divisible (into trillionths), verifiable (through everyone’s block chain), easy to store (paper or electronic), fungible (each bitcoin is equal), difficult to counterfeit (cryptographically impossible), and can achieve widespread use – many of the technologists that brought us advances on the Internet are now working overtime to improve Bitcoin.

Proponents of the role of government argue that a currency with fixed supply will fail. They posit that inflation is required to keep people spending and that prices and wages are still as sticky as they were decades ago. They overlook that the world functioned on fixed money supplies until 40 years ago (the gold standard), and that bitcoin can gather many uses and value long before it has to become the main currency in which all prices are denominated. Another fear is that a central actor could take over the Bitcoin computing network – but the combined Bitcoin distributed supercomputer runs at the equivalent of 2,250 PetaFLOPS, 90x the rate of the fastest supercomputer (note – in Nov, it’s now 48,000 PetaFLOPS!), and consumes an infinitesimal fraction of the resources used by a bloated banking system. Many label it as a speculative pyramid scheme – without realizing that all government-printed money is such. To the extent anyone holds cash over other assets, they are speculating that other assets will decline in relative value. Concerns abound over the security of the encryption scheme, the speed of transactions, the size of the block chain, the irreversibility of the transactions, and the potential for hacking and theft. All are fixable through third-party services and protocol upgrades. It’s better to think about Bitcoin the protocol as Bitcoin 1.0, destined to evolve just as HTTP 1.0 evolved beyond of simple text and image-only web-browsers.

So why not just use Pounds or Dollars? One can use bitcoins as high-powered money with distinct advantages. Bitcoins, like cash, are irrevocable. Merchants don’t have to worry about shipping a good, only to have a customer void the credit card transaction and charge-back the sale. Bitcoins are easy to send – instead of filling forms with your address, credit card number, and verification information, you just send money to a destination address. Each such address is uniquely generated for that single transaction, and therefore easily verifiable. Bitcoins can be stored as a compact number, traded by mere voice, printed on paper, or sent electronically. They can be stored as a passphrase that exists only in your head! There is no threat of money printing by a bankrupt government to dilute your savings. Transactions are pseudonymous – the wallets do not, by default have names attached to them, although transaction chains are easy to trace. It has near-zero transaction costs – you can use it for micropayments, and it costs the same to send 0.1 bitcoins or 10,000 bitcoins. Finally, it is global – so a Nigerian citizen can use it to safely transact with a US company, no credit or trust required.

Even more importantly, Bitcoin the protocol will enable financial services transactions that are not possible today or require expensive and powerful third-parties.

Bitcoin has a scripting language which enables more than a “send money from X to Y” transaction. A Bitcoin transaction can require M of N parties to approve a transaction. Imagine Wills that automatically unlock when most of the heirs agree that their parent has passed, no lawyer required. Or business accounts that require two of any three trusted signatures to approve an expenditure. Or wire escrows that go through when any arbiter agrees that the supplier sent the goods to the buyer. Or wallets that are socially secured by your friends and family. Or an allowance account accessible by the child and either of two parents. Or a crowdfunding of a Kickstarter project that pays out on milestones, based on the majority of the backers approving the next payment. The escrow in each case can be locked so that the arbiters can’t take the money themselves – only approve or deny the transaction.

The scripting language can also unlock transactions based on other parameters. Unlocking them over time can enable automatic mortgage, trust, and allowance payouts. Unlocking them on guessable numbers creates a lottery auditable by third parties. One can even design smart property – for example, a car’s electronic key so that when and only when a payment is made by the car buyer to the seller, the seller’s car key stops working and the buyer’s car key (or mobile phone) starts the car. Imagine your self-driving car negotiating traffic, paying fractional bitcoin to neighboring cars in exchange for priority.

Everyone has a copy of the Bitcoin block chain, so anyone can verify your transactions. You can write software that will crawl the block chain and generate automatic accounting histories for tax and verification purposes. You can engaged in “Trusted Timestamping” – take a cryptographic signature of any document, timestamp it, and put it into the block chain. Anyone can verify that the document existed at a given time. If you sign the document with your private key and another party signs it with theirs, it becomes an undeniable mutually-signed contract. This entirely eliminates notaries and websites like https://www.proofofexistence.com/ are showing the concept. The Namecoin project is building a distributed Domain Name System that allocates and resolve Domain Names without needing ICANN or Verisign, by using the block chain to establish proof-of-ownership. Similarly, look for entrepreneurs to apply this authoritative proof-of-ownership to built P2P Stock and Bond Exchanges – at least one Bitcoin site, “Satoshi Dice,” has sold shares and issues dividends without using a stock exchange. The ownership and dividends are easily verifiable by anyone who wants to look inside the block chain. Predictious.com is combining the transaction scripting and the verifiability to create a prediction market in which you cannot be cheated and third-party arbiters can allocate the winnings.

Bitcoin’s “send-only” and irreversible nature makes it much less vulnerable to theft. Today, anyone with your Credit Card or E-Checque (ACH) information can pull money from your account. This creates chargebacks, expensive dispute resolution and merchants double-checking your identity. Bitcoin is send only. Anyone who has received bitcoins from you can’t request or pull more money from your account.

Most importantly, Bitcoin offers an open API to create secure, scriptable e-cash transactions. Just as the web democratized publishing and development, Bitcoin can democratize building new financial services. Contracts can be entered into, verified, and enforced completely electronically, using any third-party that you care to trust, or by the code itself. For free, within minutes, without possibility of forgery or revocation. Any competent programmer has an API to cash, payments, escrow, wills, notaries, lotteries, dividends, micropayments, subscriptions, crowdfunding, and more. While the traditional banks and credit card companies lock down access to their payments infrastructure to a handful of trusted parties, Bitcoin is open to all.

Silicon Valley knows a platform when it sees it, and is aflame with Bitcoin. Teams of brilliant young programmers, entranced by the opportunity, are working on Exchanges (Payward, Buttercoin, Vaurum), Futures Markets (ICBIT), Hardware Wallets (BitCoinCard, Trezor, etc), Payment Processors (bitpay.com), Banks, Escrow companies, Vaults, Mobile Wallets, Remittance Networks (bitinstant.com), Local Trading networks (localbitcoins.com), and more.

Looming over them is how governments view Bitcoin and the entrenched financial powers it threatens. The last few decades have seen a move towards a cashless society, where every transaction is tracked, reported, and controlled. Bitcoin takes powers from the central actors and returns it to merchants and consumers, savers and borrowers. Bitcoin brings back some pseudonymity in the transactions, and can be irrevocably traded like cash. And finally, it points a way towards a single currency – it is a bug, not a feature, that we have multiple global currencies with exchangers and transaction fees in between.

Governments have been cracking down on the bitcoin exchanges, making it harder to obtain and slowing its development. Strict and expensive Money Transmitter regulations, designed to slow terrorist and child porn financing, threaten the next great technological revolution – never mind that terrorists can use cash just fine, the means of terror are cheap, and that they account for an infinitesimal fraction of global commerce. The development and innovation in Bitcoin has already begun the move to friendlier jurisdictions, where its innovation can continue un-impeded. Regulators in the US and UK would be wise to proceed with a light touch, lest they push the development of Bitcoin and its entrepreneurs to places like Canada, Finland, and the Sino-sphere. The United States has benefited enormously from being home to the majority of global companies driving the Internet revolution. The country that is the home to the Internet of Money could one day end up as the guardian of the new Reserve Currency and the Global Money Supply.

Thanks to Shawn O’Connor, Lucas Ryan, Paul Bohm (@enkido), and Oleg Andreev (@oleganza) for feedback. Follow me at @naval

58 thoughts on “Bitcoin – The Internet of Money

  1. Very interesting post ! I wish I had more cash right now to buy some 🙂
    That being said, I feel like the paradox is that volatility must be a big concern for a new currency, and “hype” creates a lot of volatility (mainly in the good direction, but sometimes going down too, and who knows in the future).
    If we take your example of “wills that automatically unlock when most of the heirs agree that their parent has passed”. It’s a great example. But isn’t it scary to have your will and life savings donated to your children in bitcoins when they can loose so much value in a matter of days ?
    Silicon valley knows a platform when they see it but we have to admit that in this case a lot of people in SV hold bitcoins and have a big incentive to make its value go up and to the right while it seems to me like they should aim for a slow, steady growth.

  2. Great post! We’re excited to figuring out away to incorporate Bitcoin as a payment option for my startup, Ordrb. I love that the processing fees for Bitcoin are much less than that of major credit card companies. 🙂

  3. Interesting, but it takes expensive kit to mine the Bitcoins, and if you want to do it with couple of your PC’s then you will have to wait 5-10 years to mine 1 coin 🙁 Its again for people with no wife and kids with 100 grand jobs.

  4. It’s interesting to look at the ‘ad absurdum’ argument of ‘changing’ money. Imagine an island economy that uses black shells as money, suddenly waking to a reality where white shells are considered valuable. Those with lots of hoarded black shells would find themselves poor overnight.

    Bitcoin in its extreme could redistribute a lot of wealth. When bitcoin competes with dollars in buying goods, dollar wealth will buy less than before, dollar prices will inflate. So then you can really say that it isn’t just the Bitcoin gaining value, but the dollar losing it.

    Great article, Naval!

  5. In regards to this point : “Bitcoin creates an incentive for miners, who run powerful computers in the network, to validate transactions and to secure them from future tampering. The miners are paid by “discovering” new coins, and anyone with computational resources can anonymously and democratically become a miner.”

    If I recall correctly – there is a fixed upper limit of bitcoins that can be mined. Once they are all mined – isn’t this incentive then gone, so validating transactions becomes all cost and no return?

  6. Thanks for sharing! So many interesting potential use cases. If just a fraction of them get built, then your optimism will be justified.

    One question: “Bitcoin’s ‘send-only’ and irreversible nature makes it much less vulnerable to theft.” – doesn’t this cash-like property simply shift the risk back towards consumers and invite an increase in merchant fraud (aka Snake Oil Sales)?

  7. I’m really interested by this segment “A Bitcoin transaction can require M of N parties to approve a transaction. Imagine Wills that automatically unlock when most of the heirs agree that their parent has passed, no lawyer required.”

    @naval can you touch on this in greater detail?

  8. Highly susceptible to criminality. Proof of ownership is in your “Wallet”. Your wallet is on your computer.
    Your computer is hackable; your wallet is vulnerable.
    AND (2nd Scenario);
    Ransom demands!! No physical contact required. (irreversible & anonymous); no geographic boundaries.

  9. Hi Naval – I’m wondering what your thoughts are re. Ittay Eyal and Emin Gun Sirer’s paer, “Majority is not Enough: Bitcoin Mining is Vulnerable”. In this paper (posted link below) the authors argue that a selfish mining strategy exists, whereby dishonesty is incentivized when a pool keeps it’s blocks private for a delayed period and then strategically publishes them to maintain the longest chain, whereby honest miners are forced to waste cycles on already-solved blocks. The question that arises, for me at least, is how can a pool keep its blocks private? Surely some timestamp function, verifiable across network, invalidates any blocks not published at tie of solution? This would, of course, render secreting blocks for strategic blocks a waste of time. What are your thoughts? I’m at orionsg8 at mac dot com if you get this message and feel like replying. BTW, I really enjoyed watching you at SF Disrupt.

    http://arxiv.org/abs/1311.0243

  10. Need help on how to recover stolen bitcoins or bitcoins wallet address passwords. Who can help? Above can

  11. Have you ever gotten your coins stolen from your wallet or invested in an ICO that turned out to be a scam, you are not alone because this happened to me too. I initially lost $90,000 in just 3 months from Cryptoallday, I contacted the authorities and they refereed me to a bitcoin recovery company who helped me recover all my funds within less than 2 days… I’m speaking out to improve our awareness of these cryptocurrency thieves and help you if you have been a victim yourself. Simply visit their website at http://www.bitcoinbinaryretrieval.com

  12. I have never believe I can become a million so soon I have try all my best to make money online but it very hard well I found my help, who help me with the help of Bitcoin when I get in contact with him I was instructed how it work and he get me connected to his mining stream which was able to get me 0.4 BTC well I am so happy today I got an apartment and cars for myself, make money by getting connected to his mining stream here is his email 24hoursbitcoinminer@gmail. com thanks to Joseph may God bless him

  13. Many people work every day only for them to not be able to meet up end means. You have to invest and be smart while you work, you are no different from those who makes million it’s because they invest and are smart about it, Saving money in the bank does not make you rich but investing that money makes you super rich and that’s the secret the rich won’t inform you about. It takes commitment and determination to be successful and financially stable. invest in bitcoin today and make a better tomorrow for yourself. You can reach digitalcurrency14 at g mail. com

  14. According to report many leading economists, crypto enthusiasts like myself, definitely! bitcoin will reach six figures but it will only take time sooner than later. You do not need a lot of money to invest in bitcoin, trust me i started with a small amount and I have made so much money in just a couple of months. I made about 78,000 dollars on my first week and this would not have been possible without the help of my very good friend that introduced me to the best bitcoin investment platform online. I reached out to them via their email at..(Digitalassetsconsultancy@hotmailcom ) I communicated with them for about 6 hours and asked a lot of questions and they gave me great answers and I was very much convinced so I subscribed to their investment package. I received almost 2000 dollars the next day and I said to myself that I will take my time to share this with the world because I really believe in the blockchain technology and not just the money or gains. I was surprised at how much money one can make just by investing and not doing anything. Cryptocurrency investment is for EVERYONE, and not just for men. I am proud that I took the right step and also many many thanks to the digital assets consultancy team for helping out. My first wallet was hacked by online spammers and they helped me to recover it with my funds back in it. I humbly have to add this that I will be buying my first house next week, what more can I say Christmas gift came in very early lol.

  15. My bitcoin was stolen and following is how it happened? A guy named, ” Robin Hacker” (obviously a fake one), He told me that I can mine for bitcoin when I connect my blockchain wallet to the blockchain mining network with the help of a ant-miner hardware. He asked me to register a blockchain account and send him the wallet id and password so he can do the connections. He also said that once he is done with the connections, I will change my password. I shared with him my user name and password information. He did something with it. I changed my password and then topped up the Blockchain account with 0.7039057224 BTC, approx. $5,700. Within half an hour my wallet was empty and that was really scaring. I really appreciate my cousin who explain more about (Mr Hallian Queen), Anyway i finally receive my BTC back and i will advice you guys should contact him just like i did.(BITCOINMININGEXPERT11@GMAIL.COM) and his expect in mining bitcoins. I will advice you guys should also join the mining team.

  16. I will implore you all to work with the professionals always….I got my 3.5 btc completely in my wallet very early this morning and i want to thank the greatest prof sydney for making this happen. I cannot keep calm anymore because i got it completed in my wallet and the funny thing is that i have not email the prof yet but i am so surprised and i know many people might need this to be financially free. I am happy to join the mining team as this is my best decision so far this year. contact him here Profsydneycryptoconsultancy at gmail dot com

  17. Have you been cheated why trading on Binary option , bitcoin or forex ? Have you lost your capital to unregulated brokers or account mangers? Are you finding it difficult to withdraw your profit ? If you find yourself in this category know you are dealing with a scam broker/Account manager, I was saved from their manipulation after i was scammed,and lost all my fund ,but with the help of Mr Frederick Morris a Binary option recovery expert who helped me and other scam victims to get back their fund back .am giving out his personal email for those who are finding it difficult to withdraw their profit or lost their investment capital to fake account managers to kindly contact him for help, he will guide you on steps to get back your fund . You can reach him on his email; capitalrefund44 @- /g= m- a- i l .c / o m”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.